What separates a CFO from a financial playmaker (and what makes them the same)?

11/13/2026 00:00:00 +0800

What distinguishes a financial playmaker from an excellent financial executive?

Think of a meeting where you knew the most likely outcome and said nothing.

Read the following scenario:

Maya, the CFO of a private Australian business sits around the leadership table with her peers as the CEO celebrated the biggest contract in the company's history. Everyone's grinning, with both pride and exhausted relief that they'd pulled it off. Maya's gut told her something was off - but it wasn't just her gut. She was looking at the report which showed the net contract value to the business once delivery, overtime and working capital had been taken into account. She was conflicted between the desire to be a 'team player' (and sign off the forecast as it was) and the number that people were choosing to overlook in the report. She knew - as did her peers - that her professional conservatism drilled into her over the years sometimes made her the last to say yes, and it often got in the way. Over the years she'd worked on this - she didn't want the 'gatekeeper' brand that many CFOs had.

Despite this, and feeling a little uneasy, she booked thirty minutes with the CEO after the meeting. She asked the CEO: "What would we have to believe for this to be the best deal we've ever won?"

The CEO was obviously shocked, because he already thought it was the best deal they'd already won. But Maya shared the truth: the story of the numbers. It was an uncomfortable conversation, but Maya held on tight. She'd spent the weekend with the COO, and together they had found two ways to reshape the terms without losing the client. The data was imperfect and they didn't know how the client would respond, but Maya knew they didn't have time to wait for certainty.

She asked for a decision from the CEO by Friday, offered to take the first renegotiation call herself, and proposed testing the new pricing on the next three quotes to see what the broader market would say.

'Wow', the CEO thought. 'Maya's not blocking us here. She really cares about the business. She's thinking bigger than just the short term result.'

This created a new baseline for the business and how it enters into contracts.

Now I imagine that as you read Maya's story, you thought:
'yeah, nah. Not in my business'
'that couldn't work'
'that would never happen'

But then you probably felt:
'damn, I wish I had the courage to do that'
'imagine if I could pull that off'
'I'd love to have that sort of impact'

Oof. It's that second feeling that will linger.

I have met brilliant CFOs who are not financial playmakers, and I have met exceptional financial playmakers who are not CFOs.

A financial playmaker is someone who sees beyond the numbers and beyond the boundaries of their function, just like Maya did. She didn't sit back, and she didn't wait until the 'red' started to appear in the actuals. She started the conversation before it became critical.

That is the difference between a finance executive and a financial playmaker.

Financial playmaking requires specific attributes, not just skills, and they're what I see in the CFOs I work alongside. This is also why I created the CFO Boardroom - because those CFOs who think they're different need a special arena to play.

A word on the name

Why not just say CFO? Because I have learned the title doesn't tell you what the person does. It probably did at some point, but the role of the most senior finance person is now so broad you're often comparing apples with oranges, and many organisations don't use the term CFO anymore. I'm title agnostic. I'm more interested in the attributes and skills together, and 'financial playmaker' describes them more accurately.

I'm curious, when you can see the move that needs making, do you make it, or wait for someone else to?

What's the conversation you've been waiting to be invited to?

If you've got a play in mind, hit reply and let's find a time to talk it through.



Author: Alena Bennett
 
Alena Bennett is the founder of the Real Math of Business Institute and a business diagnostician. She helps CEOs and founders make better decisions as complexity grows, so they can create businesses where people serve people and the math just works.
 
Chartered Accountant, mentor, author and podcast host of The Real Math of Business with Alena Bennett
 
Loading...
Grab your copy of Alena's CFO of the Future!


This is the trusted guide for CFOs to lead with IMPACT and create VALUE.

Grab your copy of Alena's Meaning Matters!


It's time for women in finance to find power in their purpose!

 ⓒ 2026
Products

Teams
Speaker

Resources

Books
CFO Report

Events
Let's Connect
Acknowledgement of Country

We acknowledge the Darkinjung people, the traditional custodians of the land on which we live and work and pay our respects to the Elders both past, present & emerging.